Posted in Music & Music Players on July 12th, 2010 by admin
In a recent high profile file sharing case initiated by the music industry, Joel Tenenbaum has been made an example of and fined a staggering $675,000 for downloading 30 songs over a period of 8 years.
How the jury, comprised of his own peers, came up with such a ludicrous figure for such a relatively paltry crime is anybodies guess. Even the judge commented that the amount was “unconstitutional”. In recognition of the fact Tenenbaum had obviously not realized his act was illegal or intended to make any financial gain, the Judge took the decision to reduce the fine to the lesser amount of $67,500. Tenenbaum was understandably relieved at her decision, but he says he will still have trouble paying the debt, based on his income. However, the music industry still plans to appeal the Judge’s decision.
In view of other recent cases, the real question should be why is the music industry targeting such small time individuals when there is plenty of evidence to suggest that, in many cases, file sharing actually helps to market new and existing artists on the Internet. Instead of making an example of individuals like Joel Tenenbaum, perhaps they should look at the bigger picture.